Best Aftermarket Motorcycle Air Filter Shootout !

Air filters, like Tunes, help your bike to breath more easily. But which one is The Best ?

 

Motorcycle Air Filter Test, Aftermarket Shootout

 

We know many of you guys and gals spend big bucks on modifying, with exhausts, fuelling modules, other electronic gadgetry and dyno time proving (sometimes) more of a priority than the rent. But air filters don’t get the attention they deserve. Getting fresh air into an engine is essential. Any limitations to air flow are a bad thing when it comes to performance.

 

Air filter manufacturers have spent years developing maximum air flow alongside engine development. Of course, standard production-based bikes don’t require the outright performance of race-spec motors, so keeping the crud out for longevity reasons is more significant than horsepower gains. This means very restrictive OE filters that look more like dustbin lids, so aftermarket companies offer performance solutions.

FB regulars will know through previous features, the boys at the University of Wales – Trinity St David in Swansea – and more prominently, Team V4 Racing. George Douglas, Francesco Cavalli and Craig Shreeves are students at the university, and combine work with pleasure by running the race team : Fat vs Thin, remember ?

It may sound obvious to some, but during their racing activities involving Team V4 Racing’s Honda NC30, the boys discovered (unsurprisingly) that by removing the air filter and airbox, performance was drastically improved; all very well if the engine is rebuilt frequently and the bike isn’t crashed, but it was soon evident the risks outweighed performance gains. That got them thinking.

So the trio put together an air filter test, gathering various aftermarket elements from MWR, Sprint, K&N, Pipercross, DNA and BMC. Max air flow testing was carried out at the university using the clever equipment and facilities they have at their disposal, before getting properly technical and analysing samples of each filter under the microscope to understand design and structure. The final slice of the test involved using engine simulation software.

 

The Test

 

 

Motorcycle Air Filter Test, Aftermarket Shootout

 

To measure air flow, the test was based on the SuperFlow SF600 flow bench at the university, which is, essentially, an air filter dyno. This allows a constant/consistent air pressure that mimics an engine’s requirement, something that you’d never get on a dyno.

The flow rate was measured in litres per second. To ensure a fair test, with all air filter materials maintaining their original shape and layout, the boys constructed a purpose-built rig from a 3D printer. Clever, eh? A 95mm by 95mm slot at the top of a vertical tube that fed the air was used to house the filters. Fire it all up!

 

The Results !

 

 

Motorcycle Air Filter Test, Aftermarket Shootout

 

 

As you can see from the results graph, the Sprint Filter boasted the best flow rate by far. There are also three obvious groupings of
filter elements; the single-layer polyester of the Sprint at the top, the middle show the woven cotton gauze filters, and the bottom
couple show the oil-based sponge filters.

Of course, this test was based purely on air flow, and there may be some differences on the frontline in an airbox and bike-specific
variances, and we know how well the MWR has done in real-time tests. But if we’re talking getting undiluted air into the engine, the Sprint and its P08 material offers the juiciest route for air, which is a surprise given how small the perforations are in the Sprint’s element.

Advertisements

One thought on “Best Aftermarket Motorcycle Air Filter Shootout !

Please Give Your Comments...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s